top of page

A REAL JEW

3 minutes ago
5 min read


MOVIES MEAN EVERYTHING is a continuing series of personal film essays by David Guglielmo


In elementary school, I belonged to a small circle of budding cinephiles. The four or five of us would take the one-dollar bus to the mall and spend the day looking more than buying, with never more than thirty or forty dollars between us. If we bought anything outside the food court, it was a VHS tape from Suncoast Video. Usually a horror or crime thriller, but occasionally a drama would work its way into the repertoire. STAND BY ME—where we learned how to smoke cigarettes—was a favorite. But as twelve-year-old boys, the last genre we’d reach for was romantic comedy: sentimental and, ultimately, for girls.

So when Cory picked up ANNIE HALL and resolutely brought it to the register, we made fun of him. He kept his cool, with a knowing smile that seemed to say, “You’ll see.” Back at his mother’s house, instead of popping in SCREAM, HALLOWEEN, or the perpetually playing PULP FICTION or RESERVOIR DOGS, he sat us dubious preteens down to watch ANNIE HALL.


From the opening, I was ready to take back my teasing. Woody Allen, whom I had never seen before, stood before an earth-toned wall and introduced his character’s outlook on life with jokes. Cynical, self-deprecating, but charming, with peculiar cadences and speech patterns. Lip-smacking and throat-clearing kept in the edit. Talking with his hands and rubbing them nervously as he spoke. Here was a man riddled with anxiety but confident in his wit, and he was our leading man who gets the girl (an ever-so-beautiful Diane Keaton—an immediate crush for me). And one more thing: he was Jewish.


These friends also attended my Hebrew school. My feeling toward being Jewish, back then, was not one of pride. Jews were, in my eyes, seldom the alpha male in the room, destined to be picked last in gym class, with looks more caricature than all-American hunk. Since my last name is Italian, people would make antisemitic remarks in front of me, as though it went without saying that I’d agree. It clued me into how people talk about Jews when they’re not around.


Though the skinny, nebbishy Woody Allen fit my adolescent image of a Jewish man, he had something else: observational brilliance. He could point out what was wrong with the world and, in so doing, float above it. This air of superiority might irk some, but to me, someone was really seeing things, apart from the herd. Calling out the absurdity of fitting in and the identities we adopt to do so. His insights (and insults) were bold, witty, and self-deprecating, disarming the women he seduced. They too wanted to see the world through his eyes. There was sex appeal in this dork. His complaints stemmed from an existential place. Life, in his view, is divided into “the horrible and the miserable,” and we should be grateful every day that we’re miserable.


Something else about ANNIE HALL immediately spoke to me. It was inspired—unshackled by the formulas of what a movie should be. When Annie can’t smoke pot before sex, her soul steps out of her body, sits in a chair, and watches herself make love with Alvy Singer. Allen brings Marshall McLuhan out from beyond the frame to settle an argument with a pompous stranger and subtitles a pseudo-intellectual conversation with its subtext. The movie bounces through time, scenarios, and ideas as it pleases. There’s no predicting the next scene. This breezy editing gives it a stream-of-consciousness quality that few movies I’d seen had managed to pull off. And it was achingly romantic. At least, I thought so back then.


A hallmark of a great movie is the way we can grow with it. The movie doesn’t literally change, but our perceptions of it do as we mature and see the world differently. WHEN HARRY MET SALLY, clearly influenced by ANNIE HALL, invites us to root for its central couple to get together. With Alvy and Annie, the older I get, the more I see a relationship doomed from the start by ego.


It’s a Pygmalion story in which Alvy tries to take what he sees as a blank slate—a gorgeous woman, WASPy and ditzy, but with enough smarts beneath her naïveté—and mold her into his intellectual ideal. He gives her books, takes her to documentaries and art films, and encourages her to take adult education classes, until he realizes he cannot control her growth. She develops tastes and ambitions independent of his and ultimately leaves him. The wistful montage of their happy times at the end, accompanied by Keaton singing “Seems Like Old Times,” belongs to Alvy’s telling. But I find myself imagining Annie looking back at those same moments, seeing an earlier self who didn’t yet know the person she would become.


Ironically, what Alvy was doing for Annie, Woody Allen was doing for me. ANNIE HALL helped refine my comedic sensibility and left me enamored with its 1970s New York City aesthetic. Growing up in Fort Lee, New Jersey, just across the George Washington Bridge from Manhattan, I began taking a different bus—this time a buck fifty—into the city. I felt at home there, seeking out art films on my own at Film Forum or the Angelika.

Through Allen’s filmography, I discovered the European art cinema of the ’60s, including the films of Federico Fellini and Ingmar Bergman. Through his soundtracks, I started listening to jazz and the Great American Songbook. I was introduced to one of my favorite authors, Richard Yates, when Michael Caine’s character lends Barbara Hershey’s character a copy of The Easter Parade in HANNAH AND HER SISTERS. I paid attention to every reference, big and small. The atmospheric ’70s chiller MESSIAH OF EVIL appears on a cinema marquee when Alvy visits Los Angeles. I can’t even be sure Woody Allen has seen that one, but I made sure I did.


I’d never paid such attention to cinematography before falling in love with Gordon Willis’s images in Allen’s films of the ’70s, especially ANNIE HALL. The same went for production design and wardrobe. Later, when Allen and Carlo Di Palma adopted a looser, handheld style for HUSBANDS AND WIVES, I read that it was inspired by Cassavetes. You can imagine what I did.


Woody Allen helped me embrace integral parts of myself: my intellectualism, my romantic side, my sense of humor, and my appreciation of aesthetics. And although I ended up dropping out of Hebrew school before my bar mitzvah, he made me want to be a Jew.



David Guglielmo is a casting director, filmmaker, and lifelong student of film. He writes about films because he loves them.


bottom of page